Meaningful Statements
Permalink Posted on 04-19-2006 at 08:15:20 pm by Justin, 257 words, 1832 views  

Meaningful statements are those that are either true by definition or are verifiable. A statement true by definition is a tautology ("tauto" meaning "identical" and "logos" meaning "word, idea"). An example of a tautological statement is, "A triangle has three sides." The other types of meaningful statements are verifiable. Verifiable statements are synthetic: they can be proven or disproven. Proveable or disproveable statements are testable.

This philosophical idea is known as the principle of verifiability.

Think of anything you believe to be true. An airplane can fly - true by definition. Improved aerodynamics reduce drag - a synthetic statement that can be proven or disproven. G*d exists - not true by definition and not proveable or disproveable. Therefore, the statement is not meaningful.

Making decisions based on meaningful statements is useful.

This is a synthetic statement: not true by definition. Thus, you should be asking: why is it useful? Usefulness to a human being means improved functionability. Making decisions based on meaning improves our ability to function in the world. The utility of meaningful statements is proved in millions of ways. You must eat to survive. Food must be produced or procured. Creation requires work.

Armed with an understanding of meaningful statements, I ask you: what commonly held theories are meaningful? Meaningless? If testable propositions about an idea cannot be made, can the idea have meaning? If a statement is meaningless, does it have value? You no doubt already apply the principle of verifiability to almost everything you do. But is there anything you don't use it for? Why?


Categories: Philosophy7 comments PermalinkPermalink

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: T/ether [Member] Email
ahh, but people live their entire lives based upon 'meaningless' statements. by definition, fate exists is a meaningless statement, but many believe in fate and act within their lives based upon the concept of fate. it's a paradox to be sure, but those who act on a framework of fate infuse their lives with a certain meaning nonetheless. is meaning the same thing as value?

some would argue for the brain's (and thus by association evolution's) creation of the god concept for the purpose of survivability. the notion of a being in control of an uncontrollable environment provides a sense of calm thereby giving the individual the frame of mind to act rationally--ironically, a seemingly meaningless statement such as god exists can help produce meaningful actions such as i can kill this boar for food rather than be terrified of it's potential to kill me (fear being removed by the notion that god/higher being is in control of this chaotic experience).

crazy stuff. we adhere to a lot of meaningless statements. rock band x is better than rock band y. meaningless in that it is unverifiable. but, we'll expend energy discussing it. one should live a philosophically sound life. again, meaningless. but many strive for such a goal and find meaning in the journey.

is it really important, and of value to act upon only meaningful statements? i would argue no, because in praxis we don't always act rationally. some degree of irrational action is good. chaos can be helpful.
PermalinkPermalink 04-20-2006 @ 00:40
Comment from: Justin [Member]
I'm not sure I agree with the statement that people live their lives based on meaningless statements. Most who believe in fate still take decisive action to change outcomes of events in their lives. People who pray for the healing of a sicked one still take that sick person to the doctor for help.

I think comparable statements aren't meaningless. Metallica is better than Aha is not meaningless. It may not be empirically testable as a statement of truth for all humanity, but it is a testable statement for me. These statements are of personal preference. I listen to Metallica much more than I listen to Aha. I must think Metallica is better than Aha.

It is of value to act on meaning. If one were to live a life purposefully acting on meaningless statements, one wouldn't survive for very long. The ability to act on meaning is absolutely essential to our existence.

If irrational behavior is better under certain circumstances than rational behavior, then the rational behavior is actually irrational, right?
PermalinkPermalink 04-20-2006 @ 10:13
Comment from: Tommy [Visitor]
Master of Puppets vs. Take on me!!! Not a chance in hell for AHA!
PermalinkPermalink 04-20-2006 @ 10:53
Comment from: carlos [Member] Email
i guess it depends on what you mean by meaningful/less. to take your god arguement, a person who believes in the existence of god has a certain set of behaviors based on this belief. so to this person, the existence of god is very meaningful, it influences their behavior, whether or not they can verify the belief.
PermalinkPermalink 04-20-2006 @ 15:25
Comment from: Justin [Member]
Los,

Beliefs (meaningful or meaningless) can certainly affect behavior. That doesn't make them meaningful as meaning is defined in this post.

Paradigms influence behavior. Paradigms can be built on meaningless statements. Meaningless statements can impact behavior but still be meaningless.
PermalinkPermalink 04-20-2006 @ 15:54
Comment from: tom jeffords [Visitor] Email
Your argument is neither true by defintion nor is it empiracally verifiable. So is it meaningless?
PermalinkPermalink 01-04-2008 @ 13:23
Comment from: Justin [Member]
Meaningful statements are verifiable. The truth of the statement is derived from its empirical verifiability. So pick a statement and if you can verify it, it is by definition, meaningful.
PermalinkPermalink 01-04-2008 @ 14:15

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))

Neal's Workshop
Misc
Search
Blog Stats
  • This blog has 229 posts and 1116 comments spanning a range from 02-08-2006 to 07-10-2008
Who's Online?
  • Guest Users: 7

powered by
b2evolution

Support these bloggers: